« Mumbai Meri Jaan: Winner of a film | Home | Mumbai Meri Jaan Review »


I AM LEGEND: THE BOOK AND THE FILM

I AM LEGEND: THE BOOK AND THE FILM

Recently, watched I am legend. A good+bad film. Those who have not read the original novel by Richard Matheson can find the film good. But I have read the book. So I found the film little dissatisfying.

The makers have taken lots of cinematic liberties that they have changed premise and changed characters. Why filmmakers can do anything in the name of cinematic liberty?

The novel dealt more with psychological status of Robert Neville. While the film is more concentrated on special effects and showing empty Newyork city. What was the need of showing lions and deers in Newyork city?

Also the novel explains some scientific as well as super natural reasons for people being infacted and being zombies’ type of creatures. Here there is no satisfying reason for infection. I also missed the Courtman and his signature line ‘Robert Naville, come out’

Initially, Arnold Schwarzeneager was considered for Robert Naville. I think he could be a better choice as we have seen him in End of days as psychologically tired alone man. But Will smith also has played his role very well.

Agreed that the thoughts and psychological status of Robert Naville can not be explained in the film as explained in the novel in detailed manner but more emphasis should have been given on showing his fear to zombies and his psychological status, his talking to himself, preparing for night.

The zombies look like successors of gollums of Lord of the rings trilogy. We can’t relate zombies to infected human beings. I think this was best shown in Resident Evil movies.

The house of Naville was not convincing. There should be generators, lights, and fencing shown around his house.

Climax is totally different from novel. Though novel convincingly explains reason of Robert Neville being as legend, the movie explains it quite differently and somewhat satisfactorily.

Filed Under tags Movies, Review, Thoughts , , , ,
Make this blog-post famous »
  • IndianPad
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • MySpace
  • StumbleUpon
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Google
  • Live
  • Technorati
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • Propeller
  • Blogsvine
  • co.mments
  • De.lirio.us
  • Blogosphere News
  • Mixx
Recommend this post!
1 readers recommend this post

Loading ... Loading ...
<strong>Email This Post To Friends</strong> Email This Post To Friends

Related Posts
  1. I am Legend (Not!)
  2. THE LEGEND OF 1900
  3. A book about interesting cinema
  4. The Legend Of Johnny Depp
  5. B.R.Chopra- A Legend Ahead of his time.
  6. Lata @ 80: And Brightly Fades A Legend
  7. 14th Kolkata Film Festival - Day 2
  8. Screenwriting Tips from a TV legend
  9. Paul Newman, the legend, R.I.P.
  10. Reality Shows and Film Offers



2 Responses to “I AM LEGEND: THE BOOK AND THE FILM”

  1. Tejas on August 22nd, 2008 9:59 am

    I feel that the transformation of books to the visual media is always unsatisfactory to more or less degree. It may be because both the mediums deal with different dimensions. One of the very few movies made with very much loyalty to the original material is The Godfather. But I often have question whether it requires any creative input from the director in cent-percent portrayal of the book. Or may be it is the height of creativity that can make that complete portrayal possible?!! :)

  2. kcp on August 22nd, 2008 10:07 am

    oh yes I was also put off by the zombies in the film. WS was quite good IMHO. yet to read the book !

Leave a Reply







(Ref smilies)

Our Comments Policy : The following kinds of comments are troll capped, blocked and/or commenter's identity reported publicly: Verbal abuse, personal attacks, hate statements, spam, trolls, advertising. Please assist us in keeping the comments clean. Use the contact form to let us know if you find unwarranted comments on PFC. Thank you.