Prakash Jha : Hrishikesh Mukharjee cried after watching my film
To continue the series “Initial Steps“, excerpts from an interview of Director Prakash Jha,
taken by Ajay Brahmatmaj , are presented here.
Ajay writes
I had started my interview series with the interview of Prakash Jha. He is my elder and to some extent my guide also. Perhaps it is difficult, at present, to evaluate the contribution of Prakash Jha to Hindi cinema but he has brought a new language to the Hindi cinema.
——————————————————————————————————————————-
[Following is the translation of the Hindi Interview and may not do full justice to the original interview so to read the exact sayings of Prakash Jha, one should go through the original interview. This is simply a trial to expose the interview to those readers who can not read Hindi at all]
——————————————————————————————————————————–
From now onwards Ajay Bramatmaj will be represented by AB and Prakash Jha by PJ.
Here is the first part of the interview.
AB: Tell me since beginning. When and why did you think to join films?
PJ: I was doing B.Sc (Hons) in Physics from Delhi University, but suddenly my mind started facing different kinds of questions.
I w’d complete my graduation and w’d pass civil service exams also to become an IAS. I don’t know why but I was not liking this idea. I had to face a lot of struggle. Family had its own apprehensions. But I left everything and came to Mumbai. I did not take any money from my father. I said to him,” As I am not doing what you like me to do so I will not take money from you”. My family was angry at me. All the people were sad with my decision. I had Rs 300 with me. I came to Mumbai but not for films. I had an interest in Painting. I had heard about JJ School of Arts. I wanted to join it. I said I w’d go there to make my life. I left the home. I had to do many things to make both end’s meet. I met with a gentleman in the train. I still can recall that his name was Raja Ram. He was in construction business and used to make buildings etc in Dahisar- a suburb of Mumbai. He gave me a place to sleep. In day time I used to search work.
AB: You had come to join JJ School of Arts then why this search of job etc?
PJ: After visiting JJ I got to know that semester would start after few months. I had a camera with me and it was my pride possession and I used to click some photos. As far as work is concerned, I got my first work in an English speaking institute. Businessmen used to come there to learn English as they needed to know it to interact with exporters. My English was good. I applied for the job of a tutor there and I got it. I was 19-20 years old then. I used to teach quite older people there. My teaching activities were finished in 3-4 hours only and after that I used to hang out in art galleries like Jahangir Art Gallery and JJ Art gallery and few others. In the mean time I met with a person living in the same building where I was also staying. His name was Agha Jani and he used to work as an art director in the films. He used to deal in glasses and he had designed and erected the sets for the film Dharma. Navin Nishchol, Pran and Rekha were acting in the film. Chand was the director. So Agha Ji saw me with my camera once and called me. He saw my pictures and served me tea. He took interest in me and my work. I thought he had liked my work and though that I could assist him in art direction work. Next day he was going somewhere and it was a Sunday so I asked him where he was going?. He replied me instantly that he was going to attend shooting of Dharma in the hotel, Sun and Sand. I asked him if I also could accompany him? He took me along with him. That was my first exposure with film world. After reaching to Mumbai I had not desired to see the shooting of a film or meeting with a star. I was completely immersed in my paintings. Anyway that day I went to see the shooting. Then there was no other hotel near Sun and Sand. Shooting for the song “Raj ko Raj rehne do” was going on. I liked the overall atmosphere there. I stood in a corner and saw shooting till 9 O’ Clock in the night. Agha Ji came twice to see me. In the night he came finally and told me that he was going back to home. I told him to proceed as I w’d come later. He left and I remained there for some more time. I had got the idea that I would do this only. Now I wanted to join films. I came back at home and reached to meet Agha Ji . He had not slept yet. I told him my desire to join films.
Next day I met him again and told him that I had got an aim in my life.AB: Such a deep impact of watching first time the shooting of a film? How many films you had seen before that encounter? Did you like films before also? What was your relation with films as an audience?
PJ: My schooling was done at Army School of Tilaiya. After reaching to Delhi also, I was not like a die hard fan of films. I was a casual watcher. Pakizaa was released during my college days and that film I had seen 2-3 times. Painting, sculpting were my hobbies during school days. In Delhi I was exposed to the works of big artists. Seeing their works I used to get inspirations that I also could do something in these fields. But that day on Sun and Sand left magical impression on me. It was a wonderful day. I had felt as if I had got something significant.
Next day Agha Ji took me to the director Chaand saab and he accepted me as his 13th assistant. Deva was chief assistant then. I used to reach early in the morning to arrange chairs, tea etc. Whatever Deva used to say I followed his instructions. I saw and tried to understand everything. Some assistants were working for 4-5 years and Deva was working as an assistant for last 12-13 years. I became more interested in the film medium. I remained there for 5 days. I used to get Rs 5 daily.AB: You remained as an assistant only for 5 days and that too on a daily wages of Rs 5 only?
PJ: Yes I used to get only Rs 5 for lunch. Then Chiliyas shop was there at Juhu Bus stop. I could have lunch there in Rs 1.5 only. Udipi restaurant used to give a big Thali in Rs 2.35 and that was more than sufficient for us to eat. I got an understanding in those five days that if I remained as an assistant only then there was no chance for next 12-13 years. After finishing the schedule for sixth day, I left for Pune. I reached at Pune film Institute and got to know that I was eligible for only one course. For other courses, graduation was the minimum qualification and I had not done the graduation. I came back to Mumbai and left Dahisar and started searching a job. I wanted to join such a job where I could get out time for education also. I applied in a restaurant of Taddev as they were opening their new branch in Colaba. Restaurants were owned by three brothers and one brother had studied at Army School and he gave me the job. I used to get Rs 300 per month. I took admission in a near by college and convinced teachers to give me attendance. I used to work from 9 O’ clock in morning till 9 O’ Clock in the night. In between I had spare time of 2-3 hours and I used to study in those hours. I used to save all my money. Later I used that money to pay fees in Pune Film Institute.
AB: When did you go to Pune?
PJ: That same year I went to Pune. I got admission in editing course. David Dhawan and Renu Saluja were there with me. Ketan Mehta, Kundan Shah, Vidhu Vinod Chopra and Sayeed Mirza were studying direction there. Naseeruddin Shah and Om Puri were also there. Such an illustrious batch did not come out again from FTII Pune. Ketan made a documentary and I edited it.
But after some time disturbances started occurring in the Institute. I had gone there in 1973 and I am talking about 1974. Girish Karnad was the director then. There was a strike in the Institute. There was a tussle between students and Girish Karnad and Administration closed the Institute.
We came to Mumbai and stayed at Shivendra Sinha’s house. His nephew Manjul Sinha was my friend. He was also doing course in direction from FTII. We people used to hang out here and there in day time and in the night we used to sleep at the floor in the house of Shivendra Sinha. Ajit Sinha was also there. Later he worked with me. To earn some money we used to write script etc. We used to arrange some money from Films division, Children film society etc. We got to know that Goa government wanted to make a documentary on Goan culture. One of my friend knew Shashikala Ji, who was the CM of Goa. We went to Goa to meet her and we got the work to make that documentary. Chhabrha saab used to run an advertising agency then and we used to do some works there also. We had a passion for film making. At last we finished the documentary “Under the Blue” in 1975. My first work came out in 1975.AB: Was not your inclination towards documentaries temporary because you wanted to make feature films?
PJ: Nobody was giving us a chance to make a feature film. Documentary could be made in less money and it gave us an opportunity to show our work. From 1975 till 1981, I used to travel to make documentaries. I used to make films here and after collecting some money I used to go to England, Germany, France etc. I did some works there also. In 1979 I started making a documentary on the lives of ballet dancer Firoza Lali and her father. I visited Russia also for this purpose and later went to London to finish the documentary. This documentary took too much time as it was a long documentary. Financial problems were also there and I had to arrange money from various sources. But stay in Russia and London proved to be very important for me. I got media exposure in those 3-4 years in London. I got an approach towards documentary and realistic cinema. I felt as if somebody has shaken me to awake. I felt I was not doing much significant work. Year of 1980 was the year of my introspection. I searched inside me. As a filmmaker big changes came inside me. Dramatic picturization of reality, which is obvious in my later days films, came from that phase. Documentary was finished by the early 1981. It was 50 minutes long documentary and I had kept its title as “Dance by Two- A Story of father and daughter”.
AB: And when did you make documentary on the riots of Bihar Sharif?
PJ: I am coming to that documentary only. I was still in London and wanted to return to India. It was month of March and I was about to leave London when I got the news through BBC about the riots in Bihar Sharif. I saw the headline,” In the Hindu state of Bihar, Muslims are butchered”. I got a shock from this news. Many muslims were killed in those riots. After landing at Mumbai I went directly to the Films Division. Thapa Saab, NS Thapa, was the Chief producer there. He became very happy to see me. I said to him,” I have just returned from London and please give me a unit as I want to go to Bihar Sharif immediately”. A unit means camera and sound recordist etc.
AB: In between did you keep in touch with your family? Did not you feel difficulty in the absence of the family support?
PJ: My first documentary was released in 1975. At that time my father used to live in Motihari. He and my mother went to see a film and there they saw my documentary. They were astonished to see my film. My mother started crying. She said to my father,” Lets go to Mumbai immediately”. I used to live in Juhu as a paying guest. I used to do correspondence with my mother but had no communication with my father. All of a sudden they came to Mumbai. Then I had a talk with my father on an equal level. That status still remains between us. They lived for a week and it was a very good week. I showed them Mumbai. Whenever I think about those days I become emotional.
AB: Making of Director Prakash Jha took 8-9 years?
PJ: I find that time period between 1975 and 1981 was very important for me. During that period I was continuously travelling and learning. I developed an independent outlook after learning the process of film making. I learnt to see a thing in a proper manner. This period gave me a solid background. It made me determined and I became a daring person in life and in my work. My documentary on Bihar Sharif riots gave me a realistic approach. The work done before 1975 is not systematic. They did not have much significance.
AB: It can be said that your documentary on Bihar Sharif Riots changed your direction? You understood the importance of realistic picturization and perhaps you got an inspiration to make feature films?
PJ: I used everything whatever I had learnt before 1975. That documentary was direct and hard hitting. If you see that film now, you will find that riots were stopped by then but a tension was there. I talked to riots affected people living in riots affected area. People were silent and fear of riots was still there visible on their faces but their eyes were communicating everything. I visited jails to talk to the people. I visited refugee camps. What happened to them and how it happened? I recorded everything. VS Dube was the special magistrate there. Later he retired from the post of Chief Secretary of Jharkhand. I met him and he gave me full freedom to meet anyone anywhere. He said that I should not conceal anything. I got a courage from his approach. I used a poem of Shaival in the end of my film. That poem was published in Dharmyug and I used it after getting his permission. Later I made a film Damul, which was based on one of his stories. Anyway Documentary was finished and submitted to Films Division. Advisory board saw the documentary. Hrishikesh Mukharjee was the chairman of the advisory board. He came out with a tensed face and asked,” Who has made this film”?.
People indicated towards me. He hugged me and started crying. He praised my film a lot. Film was released but after 4-5 days only, a ban was imposed on it. All the prints were taken back. Later that year my film got the National Award in the best documentary category.
Second part of the interview can be read here Prakash Jha : Deepti Naval and I never cherished any negativity between us
Third part of the interview can be read here Prakash Jha : Politically I am not biased & all filmwalla people are not perverted
The Buzz — PFC is powered by your submissions. Send in your news, tips, scoops, hot topics
15 Responses to “Prakash Jha : Hrishikesh Mukharjee cried after watching my film”
Leave a Reply
Our Comments Policy : The following kinds of comments are troll capped, blocked and/or commenter's identity reported publicly: Verbal abuse, personal attacks, hate statements, spam, trolls, advertising. Please assist us in keeping the comments clean. Use the contact form to let us know if you find unwarranted comments on PFC. Thank you.
- Lots of soul, lots of heart - that’s what Tahaan is
- Maati Maay(2006) -A Grave-keeper’s Tale
- Recipe for a Chick Flick - Easy Primer :-)
- Re-awakening!
- Play School Rock !!
- Anurag & I… Jab Imtiaz
- Deepak Venkateshan : Recipe for a Chick
- Phoonk R
- Play School Ro
- Top 10 Directors of Telugu C
Recent Posts:
Hottest Today:

Sponsor PFCOne









RK// Thanks for translating the interview (with its inner-view intact) for the devanagarically challenged. Your title reminded me of an anecdote.
There was this GREAT director who made some amazing movies (mostly in Telugu) and gave life to a lot of actors (most of them who became super stars post their salad days).
Anyways, during his last days, his career graph was on a down tick and the industry was in transition. His most sincere student, who was also the super star, came to the director and said “Guruvu garu (Oh master)! I would like you to make a movie. I would act in it for free. I am happy for you to use my name to sell the movie and make a table profit.”
The director was ecstatic. He said “Oreyi (My child)! Just watch. I’ll make this movie the biggest hit of our lives (mine and yours).”
And thus began the movie. The shooting started, went well and, just as the hero predicted, the movie was sold for a profit while it was being made.
Last day of the shoot. Last shot.
The director yelled “CUT!”, asked the crew to “pack up”, walked to the hero in his legendary long steps and hugged him.
The hero was shocked to see tears in his guru’s eyes and was embarrassed to hear the director say in a choking voice “My child, after all these years, you have not changed one bit!”
The hero, whose eyes were wet now, tried to comfort his guru, and said “Please don’t say that guruvu garu. I am like your son. This is the least I could do for you.”
The great master patted the hero on his back, wiped his tears, and explained.
“My dear child! I am not talking about your kind gesture. I am of course touched by your kindness, but that is not it. I am talking about your acting. When I made you a hero, I was aware of the fact that you’re a huge block of wood - strong, majestic and no skills to emote. However the passion in your eyes struck me and I could see that you had every quality to become a super star, which is what you’re now.
However, after making this movie with you after all these years, I must say that I am surprised by your acting. Never in my life have I seen someone who, in spite of being in the industry for so many years, has so adroitly avoided gaining any acting skills and still has become so successful. I could not see an iota of difference in my experience of directing you for your first film and directing you now. God bless you.”
give me names. i want names!
RK,
Thanks for posting it here.
Can someone write about NIFT and Girish Karnad story?
And also more about why Damul banned and later why the award.
This way it reads like: Take the award and shutup!
this is for PFC
I congratualte all of you for bringing genuine journalism from the films and for the films.
I have always told Ajay that I never consider film journalists, as JOURNALIST…
but here on the PFC, I take my words back Ajay!
you are keeping journalism alive for the people intersted to grwo through films
ALL THE BEST!
superb!
Yes. These kind of struggles make people big and express more, sitting behind the cameras. Just writing flowery languages does not help
This is journalism. Period. Kudos..Congrats..Ajay..Jitni bhi tareef karoon kam hai!!
@Wb,
Very interesting anecdote.Thats a post material. You should make it a full post.
This reminds the anecdote about Hrishikesh Mukharjee and Anil Kapoor when actor insisted on giving another take for a scene and director scolded him saying,” Tum Kya Dilip Kumar ho ya Raj Kapoor ho. Har scene mein to tum ek se hee rehte ho”.
Though It was bit harsh for actor of his calibre but because Hrishikesh Mukharjee was equally competent editor also so perhaps he hardly bothered about retakes after canning average or above average shots as he believed in his editing skills too much. Perhaps film was Jhooth bole kavva kaate.
Moreover young actors should be encouraged. But seeing experience and reputation of Hrishikesh Mukharjee actor might not have felt bad and because when we read about an event we get different message because expressions of the speaker are not quoted and hence unknown to us. and director might have said it with a smile on his face and love for a young actor in his eyes.
@Vinayak Babu,
after a long gap!!!
I am sure with some search you may find details of FTII’s Student strike. Perhaps similar strike or some kind of struggle between students and administration happened during the tenure of Mohan Agashe also.
There is some confusion. You have read it wrong.
Prakash Jha’s Documentary which he made on Bihar Sharif’s riots was banned after 3-4 days of release.
He said that he had used a poem of Shaival in the end of this documentary and later he made Daamul, based on a short story of Shaival.
Though his documentary and Damul both had got national awards.
Vinayak,
here you may read some details about FTII’s troubled times
[ Privatisation of culture: the issues involved in the Film and Television Institute of India student strike
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2000/sep2000/priv-s22.shtml ]
[...] First part of the interview can be read here Prakash Jha : Hrishikesh Mukharjee cried after watching my film. [...]
RK,
I do visit regularly…bas thoda busy :)
ftii has a long history of strikes. The one at the time of Girish Karnad was perhaps among the first few.
Thanks for the link and clearing up that little doubt about Daamul.
I still think that it is funny that the docu first got a ban and then got an award.
dabba// sorry mate. no names :-)
RK// actually, i realized that it is post material after posting the comment. but now that the story’s been told i lost the interest. i’m sure the director would have had a smile on his face and love in eyes, nevertheless i’m also sure that he would have meant what he’s said.
[...] First part of the interview can be read here Prakash Jha : Hrishikesh Mukharjee cried after watching my film. [...]
@Vinayak(12),
It looks odd that a documentary or a film can be banned first and later an award and that too a national award can be given to that docu/film. and it may look bit odd in present era and news channel brings latest scenes and news from the location where an event has happened just few hours or sometimes few minutes ago. People have got good digestion now but still sometimes situations can be deteriorated with reporting as all people dont carry same tolerance and especially difficult times are very vulnerable in a complex society like India.
When a riot can happen with the rumour that a certain section of society has poisoned the water supply and people did not wait for administration to check the water and riots happened then we can understand situations in those times.
Bihar had suffered in 1947 also because of partition because it had large number of muslims living there.
We dont know from Prakash Jha’s interview that when he released his documentary and whether atmosphere was still tensed when his docu was released. It may also happen that censor board released the docu but Bihar Govt. did not want to take any risk. This is for sure that peace in a complex society has far more worth than any film or docu.
People can not settle differences between a family of 4 and its not easy job to handle a big state when there are big differences and people are ready to fight under any excuse and any thing can provoke them.
If a film and docu can make a suitable impact on the affected people and they get sense and see their mistakes which they did under the sudden burst of reactions and anger then hardly anyone will be able to put ban on that docu or film. To know the truth remains the biggest curiosity but do people have bearing capacity to know the bitter truth? That also remains a big question.
After witnessing intesive live reporting of events happening all over the world we can say that media does not always show the truth and they just follow reporting as they have to report something all the time. Its not their concern whether its true or false. They have to report.
and people’s opinion change every day because of this irresponsible reporting. Latest we can see in Arushi case.
Anyway as Prakash Jha’s doc. had got national award so naturally ban should have been lifted after some time.
His artistic abilities were rewarded.
All details can be known through proper search only and after seeing all the documents and available information.
People get emotionally charged after seeing a falsely conceptualised riot scene in a film and they know very well that its not based on facts but still they cant stop their mental journey at that time.
Because society has been suffering from these problems since long and many things always remain accumulated against each other and at times they just explode.
and its not only in complex and developing nation like India, most developed countries also ban books and films and documentaries all the time though they dont face riots and these are done purely for other religious and political reasons.