Re-awakening!

Medha Dutt
Medha Dutt   | Movies | September 3, 2008 at 10:38 pm       Print this article!  Print


Two very different films. One deals with the aftermath of the Mumbai train blasts, and the other is all about music – coming together because of it and falling apart for it. And, both incidentally wel-received. Bollywood is growing and how!

Even a couple of years back, it would have been near impossible to make a film like Mumbai Meri Jaan and not be put into the ‘art cinema’ category. And, probabaly no one would have thought of a story like Rock On! Rock music is still a developing genre in India – you only have a handful of people who actually can identify with the music.

Mumbai Meri Jaan deals with the aftermath of the Mumbai train blasts. It’s about how different people’s lives change as a result. Everyone has done wonderfully in the film, but two names that stand apart are definitely Paresh Rawal and Irrfan Khan. The best part about the film, is that, Nishikanth Kamath lets the silence speak. You don’t have characters giving you a lecture about what is wrong with Mumbai, or what can be done, or why Mumbai still survives despite all odds. That would have really made the film a painful watch.

The characters let their expressions speak for them – When Paresh Rawal is derided by his junior for having led an uneventful career – the expression on Paresh’s face says it all. The way his shoulders
hunch, and he suddenly loses his balance, puts the message across. Madhavan is scared to board the local after the blast. But, one day in his hurry he has no option left. The fear is evident in his face when he finally boards the local, as also the relief that sets in when he realizes that Mumbai never
dies – it fights back. And, of course, who can forget Irrfan! Perhaps the outstanding scene of all is
the last shot – where entire comes to a standstill observing a two minute silence for all those killed
in the train blast a week back. That scene lifts the film – it strongly puts across the message that come what may, the Mumbai spirit will never die. It will remain. And, the song – Ae dil hai mushkil jeena hai – adds that perfect touch.

Rock On is a different ball game altogether. It’s about four different people coming together out of the need to make music, and falling apart for the same reason. A lot has been written about the maverick Farhan Akhtar. But, look out for Arjun Rampal. His is perhaps the best etched out character. This is one guy who has loads of talent, who knows what he wants, who is ambitious, and who like most such talented people bows down to life. He breaks and he rises again. Especially in the last scene when he comes onto the stage – you sense his mental strength. True, there are some cliched tit-bits – Luke Kenny diagnosed with brain tumour, Magik’s once-upon-a-time opponent being in the commanding chair ten years down the line – and Farhan’s ex-girlfriend married to the same guy. But, thankfully, the film rises above them all.

Come to think of it, both actually deal with the awakening and re-awakening of the soul. And, the never-say-die spirit.

 

5 Comments

  1. Aham Aham says:

    Well, I saw both these movies in 2 consecutive days. I didnt like Mumbai meri jaan. Wonderful script, I agree. But I was lost. I know many(all infact) loved Mumbai Meri Jaan. I just have a different point of view. I choose to voice it even if I am a minority. :-)

    Rock On!! beautiful movie. But not any path breaking film. Farhan: great actor, but not a lambi race ka ghooda in his acting track.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. vishrant vishrant says:

    do me se ek bhi nahien dekhi
    singh is king dekhi thi aakhiri
    .
    mumbai meri jaan – tv per hi dekhoonga
    paise kharch karke bhi seeti maarne ka mauka na mile, aisa risk main nahien le sakta
    rock on – i just don’t identify with aspiration, any kind of aspiration.
    .
    there is a zen haiku
    - Every body has beneath his feet
    ground enough to do zazen on

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Mike Mike says:

    Hey Nice article

    yes both films are best !!
    hats off to Nishikanth Kamath for a such wonderfull Script & direction…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. This sounds reminiscent (I think I spelt that right) of what happened after 9/11. I myself was afraid to board a plane to new york city to go to Baruch (city college there), thinking it might get hijacked and well, you know…

    Of course I know the exact feeling of relief as I did also figure out quick that nothing wrong had happened, and nothing bad will likely occur on my flight.

    The new york spirit never ceases to amaze me and like Mumbai, I can see how that spirit will not only fight back, but come back stronger than ever, despite any horrible tragedies.

    I’m not much into rock music but based on what you wrote, I get it. Life goes on, and we’ll all carry foward the strength to keep our families and communities going, no matter what. Don’t ever give up on whatever it is you’re doing. If you’re strong and willing enough, you’ll get it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

Leave a Reply