Scene 17
iView Author:
VIVEK THAKUR (Bombay, India)
Email : WITHELD
SCENE 17
I am a amateur script writer and this scene is from my first completed script, which is tentatively called Saher. What ever I have learned about screen writing is from the self help books and after reading numerous scripts over www.script-o-rama.com. Many of you over here are pros and I would need your help to structure my script before I can start marketing it. I am pasting a scene from my script over here. Why this scene in particular?…because it runs parallel to the main events and does not gives away anything about the story
The two characters in the scene appear just thrice in my script for a prolonged discussion. This is first of there meetings that I have described over here.
I am more interested to have your criticism on the technical aspects of writing but would welcome your criticism as a reader also.
17. INT: DAY – SMALL ROOM - Pakistan
A small room vary dimly lit. It has a center table and two wooden chairs around it. It appears to be an interrogation cell. It has one single door and the table has a note pad and a pencil kept next to it. The door opens and two people bring a man into the room. His wrists are shackled. He is dumped into the chair and his shackles are removed. The two men then move outside taking shackles along with them. The alone men in the room rub his wrists and then waits patiently for something to happen. He does not have any concern on his face. Soon another person enters the room. He is wearing a gray suit and has mustache.
Person in Suit:
Maqbool Mia, I am Tanveer. Chief Investigation Officer anti terrorist cell.
He puts his bag down and makes himself comfortable on the chair. All this while Maqbool is looking at him.
Tanveer:
Jaante hain, aap ab officially terrorist hain. Pakistan bhi ab aapko dehshatgard manta hai.
Maqbool (his voice is very dusky as if he is having difficulty to speak):
Ji Janab
Tanveer:
Bohat achcha. Agle kuch din mein aur aap yahaan par ek doosre ko samajhne ki koshish karenge, aur yeh tay karenge ke hamare aage ke rishte kis taraf jaate hain. Aap to jante hi honge ki duniya ke nakshe mein Pakistan ki jagah badal chuki hai. Hum ab Islam aur Aazad Kashmir ke saath tarraki bhi chahate hain. Uske liye hum chahate ki aap aaj tak jo bhi kar rahe the use rok diya Jayae, shayad aapne kaafi kuch rok bhi diya hoga, lekin kuch baatain hongi jo aap ke haanth se bhi nikal chuki hongi. Mera kaam waisi hi kuch baaton ko jaankar uska asar kam karne ka hai.
He again says meaningfully with a smile on his face.
Tanveer (with smile):
Aap to jante hi hain ki duniya ke nakshey mein Pakistan ki jagah badal chuki hai.
After saying what he has to say keeps looking smilingly at Maqbool.
Maqbool:
Janab paani
Tanveer indicates the pot with a glass on it. Maqbool gets up and goes to the pot. Since the room is very small he comes too close to the comfort of Tanveer. Tanveer pushes his chair back, he is afraid of Maqbool. Maqbool have his glass of water and goes back to his seat.
Maqbool:
Aap ke bachche hain Janab
Tanveer:
Haan, do ladkiyan
Maqbool:
Naam Janab
Tanveer:
Sara aur Aayt, kyon?
Maqbool:
Khubsurat naam hain, aap tasveer rakhte hain apne paas?
Tanveer pulls out his wallet and hands over a photograph of two girls probably of 4 and 5 years of age. Maqbool have a look at them.
Maqbool (handing photographs back to Tanveer):
Bilkul apne naam ki tarah
He sighs.
Maqbool:
Meri bhi ek beti hai, doctor hai Amerika mein, yaad aati hai muje uski lekin…
Tanveer:
Aap ja sakte hain uske pass
Maqbool:
Kaam zyada zaroori hai Janab.
Tanveer (taking out file from his bag, keeping it on the table but not looking at it):
Hmm… to dekhte hain. Aap Pakistan aaye 1992 mein gulf war ke baad. Uske pehle aap Somaliya mein the as an American soilder. Aap ki paidaish hui Afganisthan mein. America mein aap apne doston ke beech Mac ke naam se jaane jate the.
Tanveer then pauses for a second.
Tanveer (contemplating something):
To phir aap musalman kab bane?
Maqbool gives him a smile. He brings himself forward, bends on the table and looks straight into the eyes of Tanveer.
Maqbool:
Sochne wali baat yeh hai ki hum Amerika mein reh kar bhi musalman ban gaye. Log aise bhi hian to mazjid mein reh kar bhi kaafir hain.
He then relaxes on his seat.
Tanveer:
Aapka ishara samjh raha hoon mein
Maqbool:
Agar aap ilzaam ko ishara samajh rahain hain, to aap kaafi betakalluf hain
Tanveer (unaffected):
Hum aap ki baat kar rahe hain.
Maqbool:
Let me see… mein Mogadishu mein American camp mein ardali tha. To let you know something, I was a third generation American, as American as any American can be. Mein paida Afghanistan mein hua kyoinki mere dada chahate the ki pehli mitti jo mujhe chue woh meri apni ho. Asar padta hai. But off course you know all of it. I joined the army because I believed in America.
Flashback:
Year 1990
Location: Mogadishu, Somalia
We see a camp established on a barren land. A company of soldiers is marching towards the camp. A young person is standing at the entrance watching the soilders return. They all look tired, exhausted and some of them are bleeding. A photographer probably from BBC or CNN is taking their images.
Voice over:
Mein khada tha wahan, apne saathiyon ko aata dekh raha tha. Usmein se kuch dost thy mere jo laut rahe they, aur kuch nahin. Wahin kuch doori se ek photographer un sipahiyon ki tasveer le raha tha.
Voice over stops and we see the photographer stops taking the photograph. He fixedly looks at something. We see a very big vulture. The vulture is eyeing something. The camera moves back and we see a small child not more then 2 years is trying to crawl towards the military camp. Soldiers are marching next to the child and they are passing by him. The photographer takes the image of the child and the vulture in between the boots of soldiers and the image gets freeze. The image is on the front of a political weekely.
Voice over:
Koi nahin janta us bachche ka kya hua, mar gaya hoga shayad, lekin us photographer ko bahut shohrat mili, kaafi naam mila, awards mile… lekin kabhi lene nahin gaya. Teen mahine baad uski laash uske ghar se mili. He blew his head off.
All during this narration we see the photographer having the recurring memories of the child crawling and vulture looking on to him. He drinks and moves forcefully from one thing to another, sometimes totally restless and sometimes sitting quietly and looking into blank. Finally he takes a gun out from a case and put on the table. He pours him self a drink, takes it down in one gulp, puts the gun in his mouth. We hear a gunshot and see blood and some human flesh on the wall behind him.
Back to the cell
Maqbool (he is standing near the door):
Woh photographer kyon mara yeh to meri samajh mein aa gaya, lekin us bachche ki maut meri samajh mein nahin aaye us waqt. Aisa kya kiya tha usne?
Tanveer keeps looking at him intently. He looks at Tanveer.
Maqbool:
Jante ho woh bachcha kyao mara?
Tanveer:
Kyon?
Maqbool (frowning):
Abhi bhi nahin samjhe? Who Musalman tha isliye. Kya yeh wajah kaafi nahin hai mere musalman banane ke liye?
He looks into the eyes of Tanveer.
Tanveer:
To aapne amrikiyon ka kaam apne haanth leliya?
Maqbool (bending on to Tanveer):
Aap jannat mein yakeen karte hain? Heaven mein to karte hi honge. Har ek jaan-nisaar jannat mein he… khuda ke saath… aapko aur mujhko dekh raha hai… yahaan neeche. Hum jis raste pe hain who rasta Jannat ki taraf jata hai, aur aap jis raste pe hain woh rasta jata hai Amrika ki taraf.
They keep looking into each others eye for a while.
Tanveer:
Amrika mein bhi kaafi musalman hain
Maqbool (smiles):
Ab kahan
CUT
Filed Under
PROJEKT iVIEW
Email This Post To Friends
| |
|
Related Posts | |
14 Responses to “Scene 17”
Leave a Reply
(Ref smilies)
Our Comments Policy : The following kinds of comments are troll capped, blocked and/or commenter's identity reported publicly: Verbal abuse, personal attacks, hate statements, spam, trolls, advertising. Please assist us in keeping the comments clean. Use the contact form to let us know if you find unwarranted comments on PFC. Thank you.
-
Advertisement
- Bollywood in the 90
- ISC 2008 - Indian Screenwriters' Conference
- Luck By Chance - Tr
- Scarface - 25
- The Secret Grain, The Page Turner and Notes from director Abdellatif Kec
- Vaaranam Aayiram : A Thousand Things More…
- Tangoed for So ‘less’!
- The Secret Grain, The Page Turner and Notes from director Abdellatif Kechiche
- Scarface - 25 Years
- Has the Indian script arrived? The Indian Screenwriters’ Conference 2008
-
Advertisement
Hottest Today:
Advertisement
Recent Posts:


























Kevin Carter, pulitzer prize winner for the infamous “Vulture Baby” photograph, it looks completely out of context here, aur dialogues, did you speak them aloud to check if they follow a beat and are in rhythm?
I’m somehow reminded of Naseer’s dialgoue in the film ‘Shoonya’, I’m paraphrasing (AK correct me if I’m wrong) “Jo log Jahannum mein rehte hain, woh apne angaar khudd laate hain”.
And for my personal view on the Photograph itself, in Journalism, one is taught to be ‘objective’, Kevin captured the truth, yes he waited 20 mins for the ‘truth’ to fall into his frame, but I see no reason why there should be any guilt, he was only a witness to the situation, but who is responsible for the situation in the first place? Is it GOD? or America and its foreign policy, the rich people of the world? It’s the ignorant and the weak, the people who passed on their personal hell to Kevin, who made him feel guilty, that’s where evil lives and thrives.
Hey Madhur,
Thank you so very much for your comments, waited so long for the first . I really appreciate it, I am not going to respond to it now because at this point of time I am merely documenting the reaction, but there is a very strong urge to respond, which i am afraid I will have to live with as of now.
Thanks again Madhur
thanks ive copied it for my next film :d
the film will be titled ‘Sheher’ >:)
well if you ask me then
1. the para in which tanveer ask maqbool to stop every thing n then says nakshe mein jagaha badal chuki hai is a bit too long, i feel you shud keep all the para crisp.
2. Why maqbool ask abt tanveer’s children, he is the one who is getting intogated so he should not be asking any personal or for that matter anything so casual and why would tanveer awnser him.
3.The photograph thing is very strong and i feel could overshadow the whole meaning of the scene, as i feel you was too tempted to tell that perticular incident and it is not coming naturally specially the idea of showing it with flash back, i dont think this scene would be having any relation with story.
4. Finally i feel as its a thriller so the scene should be very taught and to the point as i guess this is a scene from where a new chapter would begain in the film.
Anyways all the points made by me might to totally waste as i myself have not written anything but sure want to do something good soon. all the best to you
Thanks Gunjan,
I appreciate your comments and think to an extent they are justified. Will visit the whole thing again. I have a theory for putting that particular incident that you and Madhur have pointed out. If if would have not been that incident than it would have to be some other equally other famous/infamous incident.
I hope I will be able to explain it some time later in the thread.
Thanks again
Hi vivek,
First of all I will like to congratulate u on script.
,n I hope it finds a production house soon.
One thing I notice above is that u have used ur
Character name as MAQBOOL MIA , n the first thing which strikes
My mind on reading it is the maqbool character from vishal bhardwaj
Movie
Thanks Priyanka for your encouraging comments and rating off course
As for the name of the characters its not very important to the script as in name does not describes the nature or motivations of the characters. So if any body demands the modification I will have absolutely no issues.
As for the length of the scene I was very confident about it before posting over here. Seems like, may have to rework. But since these two characters appear only thrice in the script I thought it will be good to explain what there motivations are, hence prolonged conversation. Will have a re-look.
Thanks again
Hi , my name is priyank(male) not priyanka
Well I have just gone through the scene again..n finds that the scene is easy to visualize
N there are no confusing shots emerging..
But I think the line s in which maqbool ask tanveer about his daughter n tanveer shows
Photograph can be removed ..reason being he is cross examining n interrogating maqbool not vica versa
Oh so you are a dude!
Sorry mate, mind see what it chooses to see
Thanks Priyank for taking the efforts. I wanted it to be a little laid back kinnda scene. Maqbool (may be) belongs to one of those groups which were close to ISI but when Pakistan came close to America, the rift between GoP and ISI widened. But before that people like Tanveer dealt with people like Maqbool quite often, so both of them know what they are dealing with. Tanveer knows that he needs the information and so does Maqbool. Each knows the limit to which they will push each other so there is no sense of panic in behavior of Maqbool. Therefore Tanveer will do what Maqbool wants him to do, it that is not out of ordinary. He knows the Maqbool is trying to playing him and he is playing along, all for the cause.
If you have seen “Drohkal” (Om Puri and Ashish Vidhyarthi) or may be “Just Cause” the scene between Sean Connery and Ed Harris starts of like that, because character of Sean Connery needs information and character of Ed Harris has nothing to loose.
Hello buddy !!
Nice scene ..
i m sure the actor who is going to play these character will get more chance to show his acting skill..
nice scene..
and all the best for future plan !!
god bless u !!!
Thanks Mangesh,
It would be interesting to know who you visualize as playing these two characters.
hey man u’ve done a fabulous job,the urdu dialogues are nice too,how did u learn this art of screen-writing actually i am also very much interested in it,i am writing a script but i am not as good as u,well do use any software like final draft or something else,if yes then from where did u get it?please do reply me i’ll be waiting.
happy new year and best of luck.
This is real and nice that now all anti terrirism cell and all in one is now Asif Ali Zardari.